Is it worth breaking a fixed-rate mortgage in 2026?
A lower rate doesn’t automatically mean you should break your mortgage. Here’s the break-even math that decides it — and the situations where staying put wins.
5 min readMortgage
Estimate the cost to break a mortgage in Canada. Compare three months’ interest with the interest rate differential (IRD), then see whether a lower rate could recover the penalty and switching costs.
Enter your numbers — the estimate updates instantly.
The rate your lender uses to calculate the IRD.
Legal, appraisal, discharge fees and cash-back repayment.
Estimated penalty vs refinance savings.
Estimated penalty
Illustrative estimate only. Actual penalties can include lender-specific IRD methods, compounding, fees, cash-back repayment and contract terms. Ask your lender for a written payout statement before acting.
See what rates you actually qualify for and whether the savings beat the penalty — before you sign anything.
Compare Today’s Best RatesA mortgage penalty is the fee your lender charges for breaking a closed mortgage early — paying it out, refinancing, or selling before the term ends. Variable-rate penalties are typically three months’ interest; fixed-rate penalties are the greater of three months’ interest or the interest rate differential (IRD), which can run into the tens of thousands.
| Mortgage type | Typical penalty method |
|---|---|
| Closed fixed-rate | Greater of three months’ interest or IRD |
| Closed variable-rate | Three months’ interest |
| Open mortgage | Usually no penalty |
The calculator runs two penalty formulas, then builds a refinance comparison from your inputs. Every result on the page comes from these steps:
Take the calculator’s defaults: a $400,000 balance at a 4.99% contract rate, 36 months left, and a lender comparison rate of 3.89% on a fixed mortgage.
A closed variable-rate mortgage commonly uses three months’ interest. Many fixed-rate mortgages use the greater of three months’ interest or an IRD. Your contract and lender’s method determine the actual amount.
The interest rate differential, or IRD, estimates the lender’s lost interest by comparing your contract rate with a lender-selected rate for a term close to the time remaining. The comparison rate can make a large difference.
Depending on your contract, using an available lump-sum prepayment before breaking the mortgage may reduce the balance used for the penalty. Porting or blending may also be alternatives. Confirm eligibility and timing with your lender.
It may be worthwhile when expected interest savings before the current term ends exceed the penalty and every switching cost. Compare against a current written payout quote rather than relying on an estimate alone.
Because the IRD scales with the rate gap and the time remaining. On a $400,000 balance, a 1.10-point gap between a 4.99% contract rate and a 3.89% comparison rate over 36 months produces $13,200 — far above the $4,990 three-month figure. Lenders that compare against posted rates widen the gap further, which is why their quotes can dwarf a monoline lender’s on the same mortgage.
It depends on the lender and your contract. Big 6 banks typically use posted rates for a term close to your time remaining, while many monoline lenders use discounted or actual lending rates — the two methods can produce very different penalties. Ask your lender for a written payout statement showing the exact comparison rate, then enter that number in the calculator.
Usually, yes. The IRD multiplies the rate gap by your months remaining divided by 12, so every month that passes shrinks it, and your balance also amortizes down, which lowers both calculations. If a refinance looks marginal today, re-run the numbers in a few months — the penalty may have fallen enough to change the verdict.
If your contract still has prepayment room, often yes. Both the three-month and IRD calculations use your remaining balance, so a lump-sum payment made before the break date shrinks the balance they are calculated on. Confirm your annual prepayment privilege and its deadline with your lender first, since the payment must land before the payout is processed.
Everything the refinance costs beyond the penalty: legal fees for the new mortgage, any appraisal your new lender requires, the discharge fee from your current lender, and any cash-back you must repay. A $1,500 placeholder is common, but total all of them — they come straight off the net benefit, and underestimating them is the most common way a refinance looks better than it is.
Big 6 banks typically calculate the IRD using their posted rates — and the gap between posted and discounted rates can make the comparison rate much lower than the rate you are actually paying. A lower comparison rate widens the spread between your contract rate and the lender’s rate, which can push the IRD penalty well above three months’ interest.
Many monoline lenders instead use a discounted or actual-lending-rate comparison, which usually produces a smaller IRD. That is why two lenders can quote very different penalties on the same balance, rate, and time remaining: the contract method matters as much as the numbers.
Practical move: ask each lender for a written payout statement showing the comparison rate used, then run both numbers through the calculator before deciding.
The calculator estimates three months’ interest as 3/12 of a year’s interest on your current balance at your contract rate. The IRD is estimated as the gap between your contract rate and the lender’s comparison rate, multiplied by your balance and the years remaining. For fixed-rate mortgages, the estimated penalty is the greater of the two; for variable-rate mortgages, it is three months’ interest.
The refinance comparison then amortizes your balance at both your contract rate and the new rate over your remaining term, using semi-annual compounding as Canadian mortgages do. The difference in interest paid is your gross savings; subtracting the penalty and your switching costs gives the net benefit, and the calculator finds the first month where cumulative savings cover those costs.
Sources: Financial Consumer Agency of Canada (canada.ca) and Manulife Bank prepayment guidance (manulifebank.ca).
Figures current for the 2026 tax year · Content reviewed October 2026
Review Mortgage Assessment’s services, resources and next steps before deciding whether to switch.
Review my optionsA lower rate doesn’t automatically mean you should break your mortgage. Here’s the break-even math that decides it — and the situations where staying put wins.
5 min readHow Canadian lenders calculate mortgage penalties: IRD vs three months’ interest, variable-rate penalties, and how to reduce what you pay.
7 min readThe down payment is only the start. From double land transfer tax in Toronto to title insurance and adjustments, here’s the 1.5–4% of the price most buyers don’t budget for.
5 min read